What Is the Christmas Pickle Tradition?

Every item on this page was chosen by a The Pioneer Woman editor. We may earn commission on some of the items you choose to buy.

Is this a tradition in your family? Fake Cedar Wreath

Every family has a different approach to tree decorating, including the Drummonds. "The Christmas tree is one of those traditions for me, and to say I hold it dear is a bit of an understatement," Ree Drummond says. "'Sacrosanct' would be more accurate." Speaking of traditions, does your family pull a shiny pickle from the box of Christmas ornaments each year?

Well, it's not a funny food gag or a leftover piece of vintage Christmas décor—it's the Christmas pickle! This classic Christmas ornament is part of Christmas traditions in many households around the country. Much like Elf on the Shelf or Christmas Eve boxes, for American kids, the pickle is a pretty big dill (prepare for more pickle puns).

So, if you've gotten yourself into a bit of a pickle (told you) wondering what exactly this quirky Christmas symbol is or how the pickle came to be, don't worry! We've got the answers. Read on to learn the history behind the Christmas pickle and how you can add it to your upcoming celebrations!

Sometime between putting up the tree and December 25, a pickle ornament is hidden amongst the boughs. The hunt begins on Christmas morning, and whoever finds the pickle is awarded with opening the first gift or an extra gift, as well as good luck for the year! It's a delightful, silly moment that children always relish. Plus, the tradition makes kids slow down and enjoy Christmas morning instead of just tearing through their presents.

Unsurprisingly, the history of the Christmas pickle is a bit unknown. The general thought is that the tradition (also known as Weihnachtsgurke) originated from Germany. However, the market research firm YouGov called this into question in 2016 when they surveyed German nationals. The survey results: Only 8% knew about the Christmas pickle tradition and only 2% actually practiced it!

Another possibility is that it was a small tradition that an ornament company popularized. Beloved company Old World Christmas crafts traditional, mouth-blown ornaments and includes the pickle origin story in every box. Here's where it gets complicated: Tim Merck, the company's founder, got his start in the 1980s importing ornaments from the town of Lausch, Germany. It was Merck who wrote the company's pickle story, but no one knows if it was something he heard in Germany or a story of his own invention!

Merck isn't the only ornament-producing suspect, though. According to USA Today, Woolworths began importing and selling German glass ornaments of all shapes in the late 1800s. It's thought that when the pickle ornaments were selling poorly, a crafty salesman dreamed up a European Christmas tradition story to help them do better. If this was the case, it certainly worked!

There are several other possible origin stories of the Christmas pickle that seem to have directly influenced what the object is associated with today: luck! A distinctly American origin tale dates back to the Civil War. A captured Union Army soldier was given a pickle on Christmas Eve, and it helped keep him alive. When he returned home, he began hanging a pickle on the tree each Christmas.

Yet another story claims it is an old St. Nicholas myth (this one is pretty jarring): In this grim telling, an old innkeeper trapped two boys in a barrel of pickles on Christmas Eve. St. Nick came by and freed them just in time, and they were able to make it home on time to celebrate.

With little consensus, you can think of the Christmas pickle origin story as a pickle-your-own adventure. If you're really creative, come up with your own story to tell the kids—whatever pickles your fancy. 😌 After all, the only thing that really matters is being the first to find it on Christmas morning.

Micaela Bahn is a freelance editorial assistant and recent graduate from Carleton College, where she majored in English literature. She loves running, photography, and cooking the best new recipes.

Walmart Has the Best Christmas Gifts This Year

60 Christmas Trivia Questions to Stump Everyone

30+ Delicious Ways to Cook a Christmas Ham

Is Pizza Hut Open on Christmas Day This Year?

30 Beautiful Christmas Bible Verses and Scripture

20 Best Amazon Christmas Decorations for Your Home

You'll Get a Kick Out of These 'Elf' Movie Quotes

These Are the Best Christmas Movies on Hulu Now

25 Best '80s Christmas Movies to Watch This Year

40 Magical Christmas Movies to Watch on Disney+

The Most Collectible Old World Christmas Ornaments

The Most Traditional Breads to Bake for Christmas

A Part of Hearst Digital Media

We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back.